Head to head
DEET vs picaridin: which one should you use?
DEET has sixty years of trust. Picaridin claims the same protection without the smell or the melted sunglasses. Is it really as good? Here's what the numbers say, at every strength.
By Shannon Kolarik, Founder, Notch Wellness · Updated October 28, 2026 · Reviewed against our scoring methodology
We make Notch, so we're not a neutral third party. Rankings come from our published methodology, applied by code to every product the same way.
The bottom line
Compared strength for strength, picaridin wins the fights that matter. At equal percentages it lasts longer. At the strengths people actually buy, 20% picaridin covers 8–10 hours against mosquitoes and ticks, while 25% DEET covers 5–6 and 4–6. And at the ceiling, 98–100% DEET still tops out at 6–8 hours, short of a 20% picaridin that is odorless and won't melt your sunglasses. DEET's real wins are price, shelf presence, and six decades of evidence; if that's what's in your pack, it works. If you're choosing, choose 20% picaridin.
Picaridin vs DEET at any strength: pick the fight
Pick any two strengths
Complete protection: hours until the first bite gets through
DEET
sold up to 98–100%
OFF! Deep Woods, the shelf default
Picaridin
sold up to 20%
Sawyer, Ranger Ready, Ben's, Natrapel, the US maximum
Mosquitoes
Ticks (deer tick)
20% picaridin outlasts 25% DEET by about 3.5 hours against mosquitoes and by about 4 hours against ticks.
And DEET can't close the gap by going stronger: even 98% tops out at 6–8 hours against mosquitoes and 5–7 against ticks, with more odor and more damage to gear along the way.
Dark bar = lower bound, light = upper bound, on the site's shared 12h scale. Modeled from complete-protection studies in our research library (Fradin & Day 2002, Buchel 2015, Carroll 2010, Burtis 2024); the same model scores every product below.
The tale of the tape
DEET vs picaridin at matched strengths
Family strength
PicaridinThe mildest formula of each, the ones sold for kids and sensitive skin.
- 7% DEET
- 5% picaridin
- Mosquitoes
- 1–2 h
- 3–4 h
- Ticks
- 1.5–2 h
- 3–5 h
5% picaridin outlasts 7% DEET by about 2 hours against mosquitoes and by about 2.5 hours against ticks.
Same percent
PicaridinThe only true apples-to-apples: equal concentration, equal dose.
- 20% DEET
- 20% picaridin
- Mosquitoes
- 5–6 h
- 8–10 h
- Ticks
- 4–6 h
- 8–10 h
20% picaridin outlasts 20% DEET by about 3.5 hours against mosquitoes and by about 4 hours against ticks.
Shelf standard
PicaridinWhat most people actually buy: Deep Woods-class DEET vs a 20% picaridin.
- 25% DEET
- 20% picaridin
- Mosquitoes
- 5–6 h
- 8–10 h
- Ticks
- 4–6 h
- 8–10 h
20% picaridin outlasts 25% DEET by about 3.5 hours against mosquitoes and by about 4 hours against ticks.
Both maxed out
PicaridinThe strongest version of each you can legally buy in the US.
- 98% DEET
- 20% picaridin
- Mosquitoes
- 6–8 h
- 8–10 h
- Ticks
- 5–7 h
- 8–10 h
20% picaridin outlasts 98% DEET by about 2 hours against mosquitoes and by about 3 hours against ticks.
What it takes DEET to keep up
Matched on complete mosquito protection. Against ticks the gap is wider still: no DEET strength matches 10% picaridin's 5–8 hours, let alone 20%'s 8–10.
Head-to-head scorecard
DEET 25%
3 wins
Picaridin 20%
9 wins
The matchup you'll actually face in the aisle. Picaridin lasts longer at a lower percentage.
The strongest DEET you can buy still trails the strongest picaridin, and jungle-strength DEET brings the worst of the odor and plastic damage.
The only true apples-to-apples. Equal dose, roughly three more hours from picaridin.
The light formulas sold for kids. A 5% picaridin matches a 15% DEET, and 10% picaridin passes it.
The gap widens in tick country. Picaridin's tick window grows with its mosquito window; DEET's barely moves past 30%, and it's weaker still against lone star ticks.
Concentration extends duration, not strength. Neither active repels "harder" at a higher percentage; it just lasts longer, and DEET stops gaining early.
Per hour of protection the gap narrows, since you reapply DEET sooner, but bottle for bottle DEET is cheaper.
DEET and picaridin concentrations, side by side
Every strength on the shelf, on one scale
Thick bar: complete mosquito protection. Thin bar: complete tick protection. Dark = lower bound, light = upper bound. Bold percentages are the strengths most people buy.
ticks 1.5–2 h
ticks 4–6 h
ticks 4–6 h
ticks 4–6 h
ticks 5–7 h
ticks 5–7 h
ticks 3–5 h
ticks 5–8 h
ticks 5–8 h
ticks 8–10 h
The shape tells the story. DEET's bars stop growing around 30%: going from 25% to 98% buys one or two more hours, because concentration extends duration, not strength, and the curve flattens early. Picaridin's bars keep climbing to its 20% ceiling, and its tick bars climb with them. Even the lightest picaridin most stores carry (10%) lands where mid-to-high DEET does. Same 12 h scale used across the site; modeled from dose-response and tick studies in our research library.
Which should you pick?
Choose Picaridin if…
- You want the longest hands-off protection from one application: buy 20%
- You're in tick country (Lyme, anaplasmosis, or alpha-gal range)
- You can't stand repellent odor or greasy skin
- You'll wear it near sunglasses, phones, rain gear, or fishing line
- It's going on kids (over 2 months) or the whole family: 10% picaridin beats any family-strength DEET
Skip the 5% formulas unless it's a short outing; 20% costs about the same and lasts twice as long. See the top-scored 20% picaridin
Choose DEET if…
- It's simply what's on the shelf when you need cover now
- You want the single most-studied repellent on earth
- Price per bottle is the deciding factor
- You already trust it and have no reason to switch
If you buy DEET, 25–30% is the sweet spot. Above that you pay in odor and gear damage for an hour or two at most. See the top-scored DEET
Top-scored products, by how long you need cover
Grouped by protection tier rather than by active, because that is the question you are actually answering at the shelf. Scores come from our published methodology, applied by code to every product the same way.
All day on one application
8–10 hHike-to-campfire cover without reapplying. Only one active gets here.
Picaridin20%
All picaridinDEET
Most of a day
5–8 hA full afternoon and evening. Mid-strength picaridin lands here, and so does every DEET from 20% to 100%.
Picaridin10–15%
All picaridinDEET20–100%
All DEETA short outing
1–4 hA walk, a cookout, a ball game. The lightest formulas of each, often marketed for families.
Picaridinunder 10%
All picaridinDEETunder 20%
All DEETFrequently asked questions
Is 100% DEET stronger than 20% picaridin?
No. Concentration changes how long a repellent lasts, not how hard it repels, and DEET's duration flattens above roughly 30%. Jungle-strength DEET (98–100%) gives about 6–8 hours of complete mosquito protection and 5–7 against ticks. A 20% picaridin gives 8–10 hours against both, with no odor and no damage to plastics. The strongest DEET you can buy still comes up short of the strongest picaridin.
What percentage of picaridin should I buy?
20% for almost everyone. It's the US maximum, it's what most brands sell (Sawyer, Ranger Ready, Ben's, Natrapel, Proven), and it costs about the same as the lighter formulas while lasting 8–10 hours. A 10% picaridin is a fine mid-range choice (5–7 hours) and still outlasts a 25% DEET against ticks. Treat 5% formulas as short-outing sprays: 3–4 hours.
Is 10% picaridin as good as 25% DEET?
Close against mosquitoes and better against ticks. 10% picaridin runs 5–7 hours against mosquitoes versus 5–6 for 25% DEET, and 5–8 hours against ticks versus 4–6. It also does that without DEET's odor or plastic damage. If you can find 20% for a similar price, buy that instead.
Does a higher DEET percentage mean better protection?
Up to a point. Going from 7% to 25% roughly triples DEET's protection time (1–2 hours to 5–6). Past about 30% the curve flattens: 40%, 50% and 98% all land in the 6–8 hour range. The extra percentage mainly buys more odor, more skin oiliness and more damage to gear. If you're buying DEET, 25–30% is the sensible strength.
Is picaridin or DEET better for ticks?
Picaridin, at every strength. 20% picaridin holds 8–10 hours against deer ticks; 25% DEET holds 4–6, and even 98% DEET only reaches 5–7. DEET is also notably weaker against lone star ticks. For tick country, picaridin on skin plus permethrin-treated clothing is the strongest combination.
Why do stores compare 25% DEET with 20% picaridin?
Because those are the strengths each one is usually sold at: 25% is the Deep Woods-class DEET on most shelves, and 20% is both the picaridin ceiling and the standard bottle. It's a fair shelf comparison, but it's only one fight. That's why this page also compares them at equal percentages, at family strength and at their maximums; picaridin wins all four.
Does picaridin last as long as DEET?
Longer, at every matched strength. 20% picaridin runs 8–10 hours against mosquitoes versus 5–6 hours for 25% DEET, and at an equal 20% the gap is about three hours. Only very high-percentage DEET (98%) comes close, and it still falls an hour or two short.
Is one safer than the other?
Both have strong safety records when used as directed and are recommended by the CDC, and both are fine from 2 months of age. Picaridin is gentler on skin, doesn't sting eyes or broken skin, and won't damage gear, but neither presents a meaningful safety reason to choose the other.
Keep reading
Go deeper: read the full picaridin and deet ingredient pages, or see how we score.












